May 052013
 

The 2013 Agatha Awards were presented during a banquet tonight at the 25th annual Malice Domestic conference, honoring the traditional mystery. The award winners:

  • Best Novel: The Beautiful Mystery, by Louise Penny
  • Best Historical Mystery: Dandy Gilver and an Unsuitable Day for Murder, by Catriona McPherson
  • Best First Novel: Lowcountry Boil, by Susan M. Boyer
  • Best Nonfiction: Books to Die For: The World's Greatest Mystery Writers on the World's Greatest Mystery Novels, by John Connolly/Declan Burke
  • Best Short Story: "Mischief in Mesopotamia", by Dana Cameron, Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine
  • Best Children's/Young Adult Novel: The Code Busters Club, Case #2: The Haunted Lighthouse, by Penny Warner

For a complete list of nominees and winners (including information about winners in past years, click here.

In addition, these special awards and honors were also presented:

  • Lifetime Achievement Award: Aaron Elkins
  • Amelia Award: Carolyn Hart
  • Guest of Honor: Laurie R. King
  • International Guest of Honor: Peter Robinson
  • Fan Guest of Honor: Cindy Silberblatt

Congratulations to all the nominees and winners!

Mar 112013
 

Time to keep a New Year's resolution. At the beginning of the year, I promised readers that I would try to start talking about newer authors who are still writing what we like to call traditional mysteries - mysteries with puzzles, where the plots are at least as important as the psychological trappings of the characters.

With that promise in mind, I'd like to present British historian and author Paul Doherty, an amazingly prolific writer, the author of more than 80 books so far, with several series of historical mysteries to his credit - and with a healthy respect for the classic traditions of great mystery writing.

Consider the case of "The Nightingale Gallery," published in 1991, the first of a dozen books to feature Brother Athelstan, a Dominican friar and the assistant to the King's Coroner, Sir John Cranston, in late-14th century London. "The Nightingale Gallery is the subject of today's audio review on the Classic Mysteries podcast, and you can listen to the entire review by clicking here.

In “The Nightingale Gallery,” a wealthy merchant, Sir Thomas Springall, is murdered, apparently by having drunk from a chalice filled with poisoned wine. The murderer, it appears, was Sir Thomas’s servant, who had quarreled with his master earlier in the day – and, after giving his master the poisoned drink, the servant apparently hanged himself in a fit of remorse. It is far too pat and easy a solution for Brother Athelstan and Sir John to accept – particularly as there are more mysterious deaths to be accounted for. And, as they investigate, it becomes clear that there is a good deal more at stake than just the murder of a rich businessman – for it could involve a struggle for control of the English throne.

This story takes place in a vibrant London presented richly enough to become almost a character itself in the book. Doherty is a historian and the headmaster of a high school in Woodford Green, Essex. In this series of mysteries called collectively "The Sorrows of Brother Athelstan," Doherty takes readers into medieval London - a place of considerable crime, squalor, filth, with occasional intervals of hope and cheer. You can smell the stench of Doherty's London as you read the books.

Paul Doherty is new to me, but I intend to read a lot more of his books and try his different series. I was led to him by the blogger who calls himself "Puzzle Doctor" at the blog called "In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel"; you'll find his thumbnail sketches of some of the stories about Brother Athelstan and Sir John Cranston here.

"The Nightingale Gallery" was originally published under the pseudonym "Paul Harding," but it has been reissued under Paul Doherty's name. It doesn't appear to be in print, but it is readily available as an e-book for Kindle and, I presume, other formats as well.

Feb 072013
 
I read this book the beginning of last month having only learned of its existence around Christmas when it was named one of the Best Books of 2012. Sailor Twain was published in October last year and for the past four months has been celebrated by professional reviewers, bloggers and graphic novel fans all over the world. I feel that with so much well deserved attention for this marvelous and singular graphic novel that anything I might have to offer would be like plopping ketchup on the world's most perfect steak. Instead I'll give the most bare bones summary and allow you to get lost in the artwork.

The story takes place in nineteenth century upstate New York and incorporates all sorts of legends and history about the Hudson River, a brief overview of the passenger steamship business, mythology both old and new about mermaids and sirens, and -- probably my favorite part -- displays an obvious love for books and book collecting.

That's it from me. Let Mark Siegel's evocative charcoal drawings mesmerize you as they did me. No doubt you, too, will find yourself under the magical spell of this nameless mermaid, headed against your will to your local bookstore where you will demand a copy of Sailor Twain be produced at once. You'll have to own a copy. It's a beautiful book both as an object and a story, one I know I'll hang onto for a very long time.



 Posted by at 5:50 pm
Feb 052013
 
As you may already have heard, British researchers are pretty well convinced that the human skeleton found buried in the ruins deep beneath a parking lot in the English city of Leicester last Autumn belonged to King Richard III, who died on a nearby battlefield in 1485.

No, this is no joke. You can find full details in this excellent story from the New York Times, written by John F. Burns. You may remember Richard III, vilified by Shakespeare and so many others, as the so-called "Wicked Uncle" of history, responsible for the murder of his two young nephews. As Burns points out, that assessment of Richard may now be challenged again:

"Among those who found his remains, there is a passionate belief that new attention drawn to Richard by the discovery will inspire a reappraisal that could rehabilitate the medieval king and show him to be a man with a strong sympathy for the rights of the common man, who was deeply wronged by his vengeful Tudor successors. Far from the villainous character memorialized in English histories, films and novels, far from Shakespeare’s damning representation of him as the limping, withered, haunted murderer of his two princely nephews, Richard III can become the subject of a new age of scholarship and popular reappraisal, these enthusiasts believe."

That argument was made more than sixty years ago in one of the finest historical mysteries ever written: Josephine Tey's "The Daughter of Time." Tey used her detective, Inspector Alan Grant, and the techniques of the classic detective story to examine the case of Richard III. The book's conclusion: King Richard was framed. It's a viewpoint that was not new even then, but one that has remained controversial. The new discovery of Richard's skeleton will reinvigorate the discussion. It is unlikely to settle the argument, however. As one of the characters observes, in "The Daughter of Time":

“It’s an odd thing but when you tell someone the true facts of a mythical tale they are indignant not with the teller but with you. They don’t want to have their ideas upset. It rouses some vague uneasiness in them, I think, and they resent it. So they reject it and refuse to think about it. If they were merely indifferent it would be natural and understandable. But it is much stronger than that, much more positive. They are annoyed. Very odd, isn’t it?”

Indeed. If you're a lover of classic mysteries and haven't read "The Daughter of Time," please do yourself a favor and read this remarkable book. Perhaps the old proverb is right and truth really is the daughter of time...

May 312012
 

When I am asked which of Robert Van Gulik's mysteries featuring Judge Dee is my favorite, my answer is always the same: "Necklace and Calabash." First published in 1967, the year Van Gulik died, it is one of the best-developed stories in the series.

Looking back, I find that I did a podcast review of "Network and Calabash" just about five years ago, before I started the blog. You can listen to the full review by clicking here.

The story begins with Judge Dee, the magistrate of Poo-Yang, stopping off in a small place called Rivertown, on his way home. He is hoping for a few quiet days of relaxation before he takes up his official duties again. But, of course, if that were to happen there would be no book, so he is quickly pressed into service, first by the military authorities who are in charge of Rivertown, and then by the Third Princess, the emperor's daughter who lives in her summer residence, the Water Palace, located just outside Rivertown. A valuable necklace has been stolen, and the theft appears to be connected to a large, malevolent plot, whose outline is only dimly visible. Judge Dee must also solve the gruesome murder of a young cashier at one of the Rivertown inns, as well as the mysterious disappearance of the innkeeper's wife.

There are wonderful characters in "Necklace and Calabash," including a Taoist monk, known as Master Gourd, who plays a major role in the mystery - even, at one point, saving Judge Dee's life. The Third Princess is also fascinating, and the various military officers and palace guards are memorable.

While the book does follow many of the traditions of the Chinese detective story, it is quite definitely "westernized" for the enjoyment of today's readers. The Judge Dee books, set in 7th Century Imperial China, were among the first "historical" mysteries. If you haven't met Judge Dee, "Necklace and Calabash" makes a perfect introduction.

May 282012
 

The sceen itself was a beautiful work of art, showing the four seasons and, at the same time, the progress of a man's relationship with a beloved woman. Only somebody modified the last panel of the screen so that it appeared to show the man stabbing the woman to death. Was the magistrate who owned the screen losing his mind? And did he, in fact, murder his wife?

That's the heart of the mystery Judge Dee must solve in seventh century China, in "The Lacquer Screen," by Robert Van Gulik. The book is the subject of today's audio review on the Classic Mysteries podcast, and you can listen to the entire review by clicking here.

I have written before about the marvelous mysteries by Van Gulik, a Dutch diplomat who became an ardent Orientalist, a connoisseur of Chinese history, art and literature. In 1949, he translated a Chinese detective story about Judge Dee, an actual historical figure who lived in seventh century China. He later went on to write sixteen novels of his own about Judge Dee, with a great deal of colorful background about life in ancient China.

In "The Lacquer Screen," published in 1962, Judge Dee, on his way home from a conference, stops in a neighboring district. He finds the magistrate of that district deeply distraught: his wife has disappeared. The magistrate confides his fears about his own sanity to Judge Dee, who reluctantly agrees to help solve the mystery. Dee quickly finds himself involved not only in the disappearance of the magistrate's wife but with another mysterious disappearance of a local businessman, who may have been the victim of a large-scale embezzlement as well.

As with all the Judge Dee mysteries, "The Lacquer Screen" is filled with memorable characters - wait until you meet "The Corporal," the boss of the local underground, when Judge Dee disguises himself as a petty thief to try to solve the puzzle. The Judge Dee books are a total delight - well plotted mysteries, set against the fascinating culture of Imperial China, a culture unfamiliar to many readers. "The Lacquer Screen" is a thoroughly entertaining book. It is available in print and also as an e-book for the Amazon Kindle.

May 042012
 
Captain Jeremy Cork first appeared in "The Margrave of Virginia" in the August 1975 issue of Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine. Further exploits of this 18th century inventor, speculator and amateur sleuth of "social puzzles" would appear over the next year and half. Eventually author S.S. Rafferty penned one adventure with Cork and his yeoman financier Wellman Oaks for each of the original thirteen colonies. All thirteen stories were collected in a rather scarce, but nonetheless noteworthy, book called Fatal Flourishes (1979).  It was later reissued as part of the "Library of Crime Classics" imprint by International Polygonics under the title Cork of the Colonies (IPL, 1984).

Like Lillian de la Torre's detective stories about Samuel Johnson and Boswell Rafferty's tales are loaded with 18th century history and lore. But unlike the Johnson stories Captain Cork is an entirely fictional creation. Described by his sidekick as "six foot six inches of insouciance" Cork is similar to many of the Holmesian inductive detectives in that he almost immediately knows the solution, alternately challenges and rebuffs Oaks, his long suffering Watson, and indulges a bit too much in his own vanity. The cases he stumbles across which he prefers to call social puzzles involve a variety of crimes from theft to murder and include a handful of puzzling elements ranging from mildly diverting to devilishly ingenious.

Each story has the additional feature of focusing on some little known aspect of pre- and post- Revolutionary War era America. You'll learn of South Carolina's Charles Town as a sort of 18th century Las Vegas with parties, drinking and hedonism on display 24/7 and that state's strange ritual of the cicisbeo lottery, an 18th century game of gender role reversal borrowed from the Italian aristocrats, in which married women draw names of single men to be their Cavalier Servente for one week. "The Georgia Resurrection" deals with vodo (Rafferty's spelling), African superstitions, and tribal herbal medicine. You'll also learn about the execution practices of that colony and the differences between the duties of hangman and coffin maker. He even gives us the origin of the now too familiar horror icon  the zombie, or zombi as Rafferty spells it. No eating of brains in sight which may come as a huge disappointment to some 21st century zombie fans.

For me there was also an abundance of new learning related to life in the original colonies. I always thought that the big cash crops of the South were cotton and tobacco. Rafferty tells me, however, that it was rice and indigo that were making the colonists all their money. There was frequent talk of slavery and the treatment of slaves (Cork is an abolitionist) and in one story, "The Witch of New Hampshire," slavery is at the heart of the disappearance of several young women in a town still clinging to century old superstitions.

As for those "social puzzles" we get the usual tricks of the mystery writer's trade: twins, locked rooms, switched weapons, and some valiant attempts at misdirection. However, there is little fair play technique to be found here. The reader is left feeling as astounded as Oaks when Cork pronounces his solutions in his usual matter-of-fact style when not one clue was ever presented. It is more Cork's behavior and personality that dazzles and entertains rather than the construction of the puzzles and mysteries.

One of the most involved stories is "The Curse of the Connecticut Clock" which features an overly complex cipher based on the musical scale and the Roman numerals on a clock face. The explanation of the code takes up four pages! You have to admire the ingenuity behind the devilry but it seemed more like an ostentatious display by a 20th century writer rather than the revelation of the 18th century imagination of the character who created it.

Historical fiction fans will revel in the detailed portraits of colonial life, the colorful characters, and Captain Cork himself – a combination rogue and savvy businessman who finds much to fascinate him among the criminal element as he travels from North to South.
 Posted by at 7:29 am
Apr 152012
 

I don't often write here about new mysteries, but I thought this one worth pointing out: Severn House Publishers, which publishes a number of very good books in many different genres, has started offering some of their historical crime fiction as e-books. The publishers were kind enough to send me an electronic version of a recently-published mystery by the British writer M. J. Trow called "Dark Entry." Set in the English university city of Cambridge in the late sixteenth century, it features the amateur detective work of Christopher ("Kit") Marlowe, one of the great Elizabethan dramatists, a contemporary of Shakespeare.

But this isn't about Marlowe's dramas - it's a multiple-murder mystery, featuring a yung Kit Marlowe as detective. It begins with Marlowe, who, with his friends, is about to receive his degree from Cambridge, suddenly discovering the body of one of his closest friends. The coroner's jury rules the death a suicide, but Marlowe is convinced his friend was murdered. He is supported in his beliefs by his mentor, a Justice of the Peace named Sir Roger Manwood, as well as by a man well-versed in both poison and magic, Dr. John Dee, an influential adviser to Queen Elizabeth. (I should note that these are all real historical figures, although these events, of course, are fictional.)

As more deaths occur, Marlowe becomes convinced that they are all inter-related in some kind of plot, and it is up to him to figure out what has really happened and who is responsible for the killings, which he does, rather effectively.

Perhaps the most interesting parts of the book come in the descriptions of everyday life at Cambridge, including the historic and often violent conflicts between "town" and "gown" - the residents of the city and the students and professors at the university. While the early parts of the story move fairly slowly, there are some very nicely done sequences, including a riot involving a troupe of itinerant actors, and scenes including the climactic chase and confrontation between Kit Marlowe and the murderer. I find less convincing some of the scenes involving "magic" (including one that may cross the line to "paranormal"). All the same, "Dark Entry" is meant to be the first in a new series of books from a veteran author, and we will be seeing more of Kit Marlowe outside his historic role in English literature.

"Dark Entry," originally published in paper last year, is now available in e-book format, as are a large number of other historical mysteries from Severn House. If you like playing "what if" with historical figures, these books are likely to provide you with plenty of opportunities. 

Switch to our mobile site